I dated this girl once who I had frequent political discussions with. This was back before I knew how stupid it is to jeopardize any kind of good relationship by invoking politics in a discussion of ideas. There was one particular issue that came up where we diverged quite a bit, and she said something that threw me. She said:
“…I don’t know if I can date somebody who thinks that [insert touchy political subject] is not/is okay.”
She didn’t say, “You’re an idiot, why would you think that? That’s ridiculous,” or “I can’t believe you…what’s wrong with you?” or “What the fuck have you been smoking? Maybe I’M the one who is not explaining myself properly here.”
What’s my point? All those criticisms look pretty identical, hers and my versions.
They’re not. When she says “I don’t know if I can date somebody who x, y, z…” she’s basically looking at the issue as if her identity is really the thing at stake here, not the fact that I might be an idiot. She interprets my diverging opinion not as an actual opinion worth having (or not having) based on the quality of logic or empirical verification presented, instead she immediately sees it as an affront to a particular identity she’d like to have or maintain…because…she’s
in a relationship with me, and her association with me reflects on her and how others view her. At that point in time she happened to have been surrounded by friends, family, and a group of people whom she felt knew her by her association WITH me: within the tribe, she had established herself. She wasn’t upset with me necessarily, she’s upset because now (in her eyes) others may see her as the type of girl who dates ignorant dickheads.
I will reiterate — her beef wasn’t with me or my ideas, but entirely with her perception of herself.
Let me add this. During the political discussion itself, I remember myself explaining what I thought as clearly as I could, while openly acknowledging how politically incorrect or unusual the ideas were. She literally proceeded to say the “I don’t think I can date…” as if she hadn’t heard anything I had said.
Self-obsession blocks the ability to think or relate to things outside of yourself. If you find yourself doing this kind of stuff, guys or girls, stop it. Or at least be independent, grow some balls, and examine yourself.